20. Eggplant Parmesan – This one that has been seen at restaurants for many decades: fried slices of eggplant combined with a tomato sauce, mozzarella, grated Parmigiano – or more cheaply with Parmesan – and then baked. Still often made in many Italian-American households, this is a dish found throughout much of southern Italy, melanzane alla Parmigiana. The only connection to Parma is the Parmigiano grated on top. Referred to simply as parmigiana in Sicily where it is a much-loved staple – and where I just spent nearly two weeks – the preparation found on most Italian restaurants in America is much more often from the Neapolitan tradition, which has long influenced Italian restaurants here. Not incidentally, its vegetable-heavy ingredients provide some heftier margins for restaurants.
19. Beef Carpaccio – Found at about a third of Italian restaurants, this features very thin slices of chilled raw meat of high quality – and free of unattractive connective tissue – that is lightly dressed in a mayonnaise-based sauce. Famously created at the famous Harry’s Bar in Venice by its owner Arrigo Cipriani in 1950 for a finicky regular aristocratic patron, the dish is named after the Venetian Renaissance painter Vittore Carpaccio whose work was being exhibited in the city at the time. The assertive color of the dish reminded Cipriani of the reds in Carpaccio’s canvases. Almost always served as an antipasto, a version of the original beef carpaccio is the one usually found at restaurants.
18. Burrata – This is a cheese originally from the region of Puglia in southeastern Italy with a soft texture consisting of a thin outer shell of mozzarella with an inside of additional fresh cheese and cream. The elaborate process to make it begins with cream being pasteurized and cooled. Mozzarella is made coagulating milk and stretching the curds. Then that mozzarella is wrapped and molded around the cream, which has also formed curds. Usually served in the ball-like form in which it is made, this mild-tasting, moist cheese is best when very fresh and eaten with just-cracked black pepper and a drizzle of high-quality olive oil. Unknown outside of its home area near the town of Adria north of Bari until the 1980s or so, it began to gain some traction in southern California with the opening of a cheese factory in the Los Angeles area in the early 1990s by native of Puglia.
17. Linguine with clams in a white sauce – Made with white wine and lemon juice, garlic in abundance, and usually red pepper flakes to accompany small- or medium-sized clams in the shell and not all tossed over long strands of commercially made dried pasta then dotted with bits of fresh parsley, this is a bright, fresh-tasting and fairly light meal that is a favorite Italian food for many. The dish originated in the Naples area as spaghetti alle vongole, spaghetti and clams in translation. Quickly cooked, with a noticeable air of freshness and spontaneity, the preparation is part of the broad Neapolitan cucina povera tradition that immigrated in large numbers to America in the last century. The Philadelphia area, with the strong Neapolitan heritage of its restaurateurs might have been its initial American toehold by the 1930s. Baltimore, New York, Boston and other places near the water, and clams, were also serving the dish around mid-century. It started to become popular in the 1950s as restaurateurs influenced by the Neapolitan tradition became more widespread. And by the 1970s, pasta with clams in a white sauce was the most commonly found item in Italian restaurants across America.
16. Prosciutto – This is prosciutto crudo, thinly sliced ham cured in the Italian tradition. This is commonly served as part of a mix of cured meats increasingly called affettati or tagliere on menus now. Or it might appear in older school rendition, paired with melon when in season. In the New York area, prosciutto often loses a syllable and goes by “proshoot.” Made from high-quality pork legs, which are covered in salt and left to rest, during which the salt draws out the blood and other moisture that makes it safe to eat raw. After this salting, the legs are washed, seasoned, and left to age at a controlled temperature from 14 months to three years. Made in much of northern Italy, the most well-known is Prosciutto di Parma and the slightly sweeter Prosciutto di San Daniele. Other top versions available to lesser degree in America are Prosciutto di Carpegna and Prosciutto di Modena. Though prosciutto made domestically have improved in the last couple of decades, the Italian products are still clearly superior, and so usually noted on the menu.
15. Lasagna – A stalwart in the Italian-American kitchen, lasagna, with its layers of boiled flat noodles usually encasing ricotta, mozzarella, and tomato sauce along with beef or sausage baked to a cheesy goodness has long found a place on Italian restaurant menus. Lasagna, as most restaurants serve it here, is inspired from the pre-Lenten Carnival version from the Naples area from the past century. Here, it grew taller, meaty, much heartier, and more American. Today, some restaurants proudly proclaim the number of layers of pasta in its versions. Chef Mark Ladner at the acclaimed Del Posto in New York even introduced an impossibly baroque 100-layer lasagne in 2009.
14. Meatballs as an appetizer – In recent years, meatballs have become a very popular order to start a meal for many. These often feature a combination of meats involving ground beef with pork and veal and are served with a tomato sauce. All-veal ones are also seen. Meatballs were part of the southern Italian tradition of the immigrants; it was a way to make poor quality meat much more palatable. Usually stretched with bread or bread crumbs, it was always served as a main course, after the pasta or soup. In America, since beef, and pork and veal were all plentiful and easily affordable, those meatballs eventually became quite larger and beefier, meatier than their Old World precursors, and served much more frequently.
13. Salmon – Salmon does not seem Italian. The fish is certainly not Italian. It is not native to the Italian coasts and rivers. But salmon is one of the most common sights on Italian restaurant menus in America, found on well over a third of them. Nearly every Italian restaurant here always had at a distinct American component. Restaurants source from America and serve American customers, after all. As about the most easily sourced fish with broad appeal, salmon has found a home at Italian restaurants in America for several decades, first gaining significant traction in the 1990s.
12. Insalata Caprese – Sporting the red, white and green of the Italian flag, this is a light dish made in purest form just with slices of hopefully at least decent quality mozzarella and ripe tomatoes, leaves of fresh basil, and olive oil. It was created at a hotel on the island of Capri near Naples, hence the name, maybe in the 1930s. Insalata caprese began to appear in the 1960s in America and became popular as a starter at many Italian restaurants in the 1980s, then a necessity at most affordable Italian-American restaurants after the turn of the millennium. It is now found at about 40 percent of Italian restaurants around the country. And it is popular in Italy today well beyond its place of origins.
11. Pork as an entrée – Other than prosciutto and the other cured items that might be served as an antipasto, pork does not typically come to mind for most when going out for Italian. There are far fewer pork dishes as a secondo, or main, in the Italian catalog than other proteins, after all. And one has not become a classic restaurant dish like veal marsala, chicken cacciatore, chicken parmesan, saltimbocca or steak pizzaiola. But pork as main dish has always been found at Italian restaurants in America. Pork chops were on the menu at Campi’s in Stockton, California in the 1890s, to cite a very early example. Today, you will find dishes an array of pork-based entrées. For the restaurant, and customer, it is a meat that is cheaper than beef.
10. Chicken Parmesan – This is a favorite for home cooks, children, and Italian-American chain restaurants. And many more, to be fair. There was a piece a few years about Ken Auletta, the longtime New Yorker writer who has had an obsession in finding excellent chicken parmesan preparations, and part of a group of Italian-Americans who have been foraging the Italian-American eateries of the New York area for years in search of quality versions. For Auletta, a “test of a good Southern Italian restaurant is whether their chicken or veal parmigiana had a good sauce, the breading is crisp and has not been drowned in sauce, and the chicken or veal is not so thin it tastes like cardboard.” Chicken parmesan is an American creation that grew from the eggplant parmigiana preparation from southern Italy and Sicily, with the meatier chicken substituting for the less caloric eggplant at its core. It long ago passed veal parmesan in popularity, to my chagrin.
9. Risotto – A usually substantial dish of short-grain rice that has been slowly cooked in a broth to tenderness with a wide variety of ingredients including cheeses, meats, and seafood, this is usually made to order with a plump superfino variety of rice like carnaroli or arborio. It’s not a quick dish to prepare, and servings for two are often a minimum order. Risotto is originally from the northern regions of Italy along the Po River valley where rice is grown. It is a common starter in place of pasta in areas of Piedmont, Lombardy and the Veneto. A feature at ambitious restaurants in America today, risotto has actually been served at Italian restaurants here since there were Italian restaurants in America.
8. Gnocchi – While at a restaurant in Boston’s North End for lunch a year ago, I was texting a friend, an Italian-American from the area, while musing about what to do order. I wrote that I was considering the gnocchi. He quickly replied that I was a brave man. Both of us had encountered poorly made gnocchi too often at restaurants: leaden, dull, and tasting a lot like pencil erasers. I’ve long thought of gnocchi as one test for Italian restaurants. If those are made well, there is a good chance it has a quality kitchen. Thought to resemble “lumps,” hence the name, gnocchi are dumplings made primarily from either potatoes or semolina flour, cooked by boiling in water or broth, or sometimes baked.
7. Fried Calamari – This might be only seafood readily ordered in restaurants far from the coasts. Squid tentacles are cut into small rings, and at times with very small whole squids, lightly coated in flour then are quickly deep-fried until crispy and served hot with wedges of lemon and usually tomato sauce on the side. The dish has become an Italian-American menu fixture as a starter. Usually fairly clean-tasting, not fishy, it is widely enjoyed. And that it is fried might be the reason. Might be. It is another of the many popular dishes with roots in the Naples area along with the ravioli, much of the antipasti spread, the hefty tomato-sauced lasagna, linguine in a white clam sauce, chicken parmesan, spaghetti and meatballs, spumoni, eggplant parmesan, pizza, pasta with marinara sauce, insalata caprese, veal piccata, and more.
6. Potatoes as a side dish – Americans especially like potatoes. But potatoes also have a long tradition as a side dish in Italy. A potato contorno, side dish, at a trattoria in Italy is a common order with roasted or grilled meats, and can be delicious. Often it might be wedges of yellowy potatoes sauteed and served with plenty of quality olive oil, noticeable rosemary and big grains of salt. Here, you will find potato sides more so at restaurants with a more Italian than Italian-American focus. The Italian-American tradition, with typically very large portion sizes, has little need for side dishes. Olive Garden does offer a side of mashed potatoes, though. Maybe something good to know. Or not. This popularity is not new; potato dishes have long been served at Italian restaurants in America.
5. Fresh pasta – More popular than ever, freshly made pastas are a calling card for many Italian restaurants and a signifier that it has a serious kitchen. These might be thin strands or larger sheets that are filled and served as stuffed pastas like ravioli. Fresh pasta usually means pasta made with soft wheat flour and eggs. The sturdier hard or durum wheat will be part of the mix if the pasta is extruded into shapes at the restaurant like fresh rigatoni. This recent popularity is the influence of the area of Emilia north of Rome – the inland part of the Emilia-Romagna region. This is the heartland of fresh pasta in Italy and a widely admired rich cuisine, and many prominent American chefs have trained in the region.
4. Antipasto plate – This might go by the name antipasto plate, tagliere, or affettati misti, a mixed plate in a variety of forms ordered at the start of the meal. It resides in the “Antipasto” section, if there is one, of course. These are from the Italian tradition of small pre-prepared items to provide some satiety before the heartier dishes that might be cooked to order. Antipasto means “before the meal.” It is what you eat before you eat. Antipasto selections have been around since there have been Italian restaurants here.
3. Caesar Salad – Crisp romaine lettuce dressed with a mixture of egg, Parmigiano, olive oil, garlic, salt, pepper, and lemon juice then served with croutons – and anchovies for those not faint of heart – the Caesar salad is everywhere and part of the Italian-American restaurant canon. It is very rare not to see a version on the menu at one, even if a relative of its creators has expressed surprise that the Caesar salad could be considered Italian-American much less Italian. Though one can occasionally come across the dish in Italy – those stops serving tourists or in overly creative versions at ambitious establishments – it is an American restaurant dish, North American, at least. The Caesar salad initially immigrated from Mexico.
2. Ravioli – Though stuffed pasta in America once meant just ravioli filled with ricotta and spinach served with a tomato or meat sauce, the range of names and fillings has broadened considerably over the years. Today, you will see not only ravioli, but agnolotti, tortelli, tortellini, cappelletti and others, filled and served in a number of ways. If the names aren’t used at all as they are in Italy, no matter.
1. Steak – Even as beef prices have soared about 25 percent in just the last year-and-a-half, you’ll see a menu item for a steak in almost nine of ten Italian restaurants across the country today. “Being American is to eat a lot of beef steak,” as Kurt Vonnegut once astutely observed. Steaks have been served at Italian restaurants in America almost certainly since soon after there were Italian restaurants in America. offering steaks were definitely not an attempt to replicate the restaurants in Italy. There were hardly any, if any, steakhouses in Italy in the American sense and scarcely any steak dishes. Outside of the Florentines and later other Tuscans, there has been no steak tradition in Italy. In fact, the bistecca in the famous bistecca alla Fiorentina comes from the English “beefsteak” because there was no suitable Italian name for the dish. But from the 19th century until today, steaks have always been the most frequently found item across Italian restaurants or right near the top.
RSS Feed